Home  >  Movies & TV  >  Movie Reviews

Movie & TV Reviews

Movie review: ‘Dirty Wars’

Posted 12:13am on Friday, Jun. 28, 2013

Unrated; 83 min.

It is possible to admire Jeremy Scahill and sympathize with his point of view and yet not love Dirty Wars, the documentary based on his recent investigative work into the covert war on terror. The film has its use, for sure, exposing America’s policy of using targeted assassinations and drone strikes. This is a policy that is morally dubious to begin with and one that, according to Scahill, has been employed to an extent and on a scale that most Americans would find shocking.

How can you not respect a guy who’s so driven to do such dangerous and unpleasant work? Early in the film, we see him interviewing an impoverished Afghan family, in which several people — including two pregnant women — were killed in some misbegotten covert night raid. The switch from Presidents Bush to Obama hasn’t ended this kind of thing; in fact, it seems to have accelerated under the latter. Scahill’s point is that such actions are not only cataclysmically wrong but counterproductive. Wiping out innocent civilians is a sure way to create terrorists, not eliminate them.

So long as the camera is on the victims and stays focused on specific crimes and occurrences, Dirty Wars is on solid ground. But as the movie wears on, the story widens, and as it does, it becomes nebulous. Moreover, the focus becomes Scahill himself, who narrates the film and appears on camera looking stoic and concerned, like a virtuous animal in a fairy tale. The movie begins to feel like a star turn, like grandstanding.

The essential problem is that the audience really doesn’t care about how Scahill gets the story, or how he feels, or even particularly how he looks. The audience only cares about what the story is, the details. More details and fewer close-ups might have made for a more effective documentary.

Exclusive: Angelika Dallas

— Mick LaSalle, San Francisco Chronicle

We welcome your comments on this story, but please be civil. Do not use profanity, hate speech, threats, personal abuse, images, internet links or any device to draw undue attention. Our policy requires those wishing to post here to use their real identity.

Our commenting policy | Facebook commenting FAQ | Why Facebook?

Hey there. or join DFW.com. Your account. Log out.

Remember me