Home  >  Ink


Which slices stood out? We'll fill you in

Who has the best slice of pie in DFW?
Posted 7:18pm on Tuesday, Dec. 18, 2012

Eating pie is, admittedly, not the most arduous of assignments. But picking a few favorites among the many standouts we tried is.

Here's a ranking of our top six. Tell us who you think is the lord of the pies by posting a comment below this story, and voting in our poll to the left.

1 Mudea's Sweet Potato Pie, Miz. G's House of Pies, Bedford: This was close, but Gazetta Anderson's tribute to her grandmother's sweet-potato pie -- sweet, creamy, with just a hint of spice -- was transcendent. For now, Miz. G's is an online and by-phone business, but Anderson hopes to have a storefront open in 2013. We'll be first in line.

2 Chocolate chess pie, Sugar & Frosting, Keller: From the cracked-brownie-like top to the rich-without-being-cloying flavor, S&F's chess pie is one of the best chocolate experiences we've ever had.

3 The Drunken Nut, Emporium Pies, Dallas: This recently opened Oak Cliff spot is trying to raise the pie game with unusual fillings and offbeat crusts, but this fairly traditional twist on pecan pie -- with a bourbon-laced filling -- is its most popular. And no wonder; the pecans are slightly sweet and strongly crunchy, and, yes, you can taste the bourbon, which gets even more flavorful when you leave the pie at room temperature for a while. (The Smooth Operator, a French silk pie with a pretzel crust, was also good.)

4 Buttermilk pie, Texas Harvest Pie Company, Keller: The buttermilk is listed under "classic pies" at this charming Old Town Keller lunch-and-dessert place, and it was indeed classic with its sweetness and melt-in-your mouth texture. Pies are available by the slice here, and we've never been disappointed.

5 Sour cherry pie (5-inch size), Black Rooster Bakery, Fort Worth: Just the right mix of sweetness and tartness, with a beautifully executed lattice topping -- pretty traditional but very pleasing from a neighborhood bakery that always has an array of mouthwatering desserts in its pastry case. Sandwiches are good, too.

6 Chocolate-chili pie, Stir Crazy Baked Goods, Fort Worth: Robbie Werner told us her favorite among her pies is the apple-cranberry, but we rolled the dice on this adventurous offering, which was divisive: Some of us (including me) loved the combo of sweet and spicy, while others found the spicy side overwhelming. Wimps.

We welcome your comments on this story, but please be civil. Do not use profanity, hate speech, threats, personal abuse, images, internet links or any device to draw undue attention. Our policy requires those wishing to post here to use their real identity.

Our commenting policy | Facebook commenting FAQ | Why Facebook?

Hey there. or join DFW.com. Your account. Log out.

Remember me